What is the best wallpaper removal method for plaster walls in older Saint John homes?

For plaster walls in older Saint John homes, the safest removal method is slow soaking with warm water and wallpaper removal solution, using a plastic scraper rather than a metal blade, and working in small sections. Plaster is more durable than drywall but can crack and crumble at the edges of damage if you rush or use excessive force.

Saint John has some of the oldest housing stock in New Brunswick — and in Canada, for that matter. The South End, North End, and uptown heritage neighbourhoods are full of homes built between the 1870s and 1930s, with true three-coat plaster walls that are hard, dense, and generally more forgiving of moisture than drywall. This is actually good news for wallpaper removal: plaster doesn't fall apart when wet the way drywall does, and you have more time to work once the paper is saturated.

The key concern with plaster is not the surface itself but the underlying structure. Old lath-and-plaster construction can have areas where the plaster has already separated from the lath behind it — what plasterers call a hollow spot. You can find these by tapping the wall gently and listening for a dull, hollow sound rather than a solid thud. Don't apply heavy pressure or vibration over hollow spots during removal, or the plaster may crack and break away in sections. Mark any hollow areas before you start and work around them gently.

The removal process:

Score the wallpaper lightly with a perforation tool — on plaster you can press a bit more firmly than you would on drywall since there's no paper face to tear. Apply DIF wallpaper removal solution (mixed with warm water per label directions) with a garden sprayer or large sponge. Give it a full 10 to 15 minutes to penetrate, especially if the wallpaper is old vinyl-faced or has multiple layers. Use a wide plastic scraper or a 15 cm stiff nylon scraper at a low angle, working with the seams wherever possible.

Multiple layers — very common in Saint John's older homes where wallpaper was applied decade after decade — require patience. Remove one layer at a time, re-wetting between layers. The oldest, bottom layer is often the most stubborn because it was hung with old wheat paste directly on the plaster, and the paste has hardened over 50 or 60 years into an almost glue-like bond. Stubborn paste residue responds well to a stronger DIF solution and longer soak times.

After removal, wash plaster walls thoroughly to remove all paste residue. Plaster repairs (cracks, small holes, hollow sections) should be done with traditional plaster patching compound or setting-type joint compound, not lightweight spackling, which isn't hard enough for plaster repairs. After repairs cure, prime with an alkali-resistant primer before painting — old lime-based plaster is alkaline, and without the right primer, the paint can saponify (turn soapy) and fail.

This is a project where professional experience genuinely pays off in older Saint John homes. A painter who knows how to work with plaster, identify structural vulnerabilities, and do proper plaster repairs is worth finding through the New Brunswick Construction Network directory.

---

Find a Painting Contractor

New Brunswick Painting helps you find local painting professionals through the New Brunswick Construction Network:

• Expressions Painting ✓
• Loves Painting Ltd. ✓
• Worry No More Handyman Service ✓
• Worry No More Handyman Services ✓